Forum General


The Xamarin Forums have officially moved to the new Microsoft Q&A experience. Microsoft Q&A is the home for technical questions and answers at across all products at Microsoft now including Xamarin!

To create new threads and ask questions head over to Microsoft Q&A for .NET and get involved today.

Getting Started Experience

xanadontxanadont USMember
edited October 2012 in General


I just wanted to send some constructive feedback about getting started with the product. I want to preface that I think the product is absolute magic and you guys are doing a top-notch job. With that, here are two critiques:

  1. Getting started with the Hello World tutorial was frustrating. First - there was enough outdated information in the tutorial to cause confusion. Second - and this is really the source of most of the frustration - XCode wasn't interacting correctly with MonoDevelop on first run. I did follow the setup instructions but I think MonoDevelop was disconnected from XCode for 1 or 2 reasons: either it was because I had MonoDevelop running before the XCode install had finished (it takes a long time and I'm too impatient ... I wanna play with the new toys!) and / or it was XCode's first run so a license agreement was unknowingly getting in the way (both scenarios were in play but I'm not sure if it was one, the other, or both causing problems). Whatever the case was, clicking on the xib was not launching XCode. So I did a right-click > open with (as noted in the tutorial) and opened the xib. However, even though IB was open with the xib, the XCode project files - and most importantly the header file - weren't automatically generated. Being completely unfamiliar with XCode I fumbled around for about an hour trying to manually create header files, drag & drop outlets, etc. with no joy. It wasn't until I finally closed everything down and started the tutorial anew did things work properly.

  2. Creating an account at Xamarin causes you to return to after email verification. Here you're presented with a blank page with no further instruction. I then manually hacked the URL from to at which point it 404'd. Eventually I returned to non-SSL but now I had to log on again before I was finally able to write this post.

I want to stress these are minor quibbles compared to the awesomeness of Monotouch. But with these "onboarding" issues ironed out, I think you'll be that much closer to truly "delighting" your customers.

Thanks for a great product! I hope this post is helpful.


  • brajkovicbrajkovic USXamarin Team, University Xamurai

    Hi Abe,

    I can't address point #1, but I can address #2, and tell you that we'll be addressing that confusion shortly by making registration smoother by sending you back to your origin after you complete the process. This should make the whole process much better.

    Thanks for your feedback,

  • BryanCostanichBryanCostanich USMember, Xamarin Team Xamurai

    @Xanandot - thanks for the head's up, we'll make sure the tutorial gets updated. we'll also make a note about opening Xcode first so you can accept the license agreement.

  • xanadontxanadont USMember

    @bryancostanich Open first for agreeing to the license but then I think you need to have it closed before you start the tutorial. I suspect MonoDevelop doesn't get a reference to an already-opened XCode ... but I certainly could be wrong.

  • BryanCostanichBryanCostanich USMember, Xamarin Team Xamurai

    Yeah, @Xanadont, we're updating it. It showed up for me the other day too, I believe it's fairly new.

Sign In or Register to comment.